The Industry Spread

Follow

XFacebookLinkedIn

Regulation

Why the Bank's thinner SSITG still exposes CCP capital

The Bank's near-final CCP rulebook sets SSITG at 10% of risk-weighted capital, keeps intraday variation-margin calls, and narrows omnibus porting duties.

Why the Bank's thinner SSITG still exposes CCP capital

The Bank of England's near-final central counterparty rulebook, published on November 16, 2026, introduces a second skin in the game (SSITG) at 10% of a CCP's risk-weighted capital requirement, keeps a defined set of intraday variation-margin duties, and narrows several porting proposals after a consultation that drew 19 responses.

Rule 2.4(2) of the Default Waterfall Part places that capital beside the mutualised default fund, consumed pro rata with non-defaulting members' contributions. Final instruments still depend on HM Treasury revoking the relevant parts of the on-shored European Market Infrastructure Regulation (UK EMIR). The sections below set out the variation-margin text left in place, the porting duties that were narrowed, and the cut in SSITG from 25% to 10%.

Key facts

  • The near-final policy statement is dated November 16, 2026. Consultation ran from July 18 to November 18, 2025, and drew 19 responses (paragraph 1.9).
  • SSITG moves from a consulted 25% of risk-weighted capital to 10% under Rule 2.4(2) of the Default Waterfall Part (paragraphs 5.1 and 5.3).
  • CCPs must meet SSITG by April 1, 2028, and must replenish it within one month after use, including after a non-default loss (paragraphs 1.27 and 5.7).
  • Resources counting toward the 110% capital notification threshold may count toward SSITG (Rule 3.7 of the Capital Part and Rule 2.8 of the Default Waterfall Part, paragraph 5.5).
  • Margin-simulator rules 5.2 and 5.3 take effect 24 months after the UK Central Counterparties Instrument 2027 commences, and the other new margin rules in paragraph 3.11 take effect at 12 months.
  • Most other rules move to a minimum of three months from publication once legislation is in force, with the first instrument expected in the fourth quarter of 2026 and the rest by the end of the first quarter of 2027 (paragraph 1.24).
  • Further porting work with the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) is expected to begin in 2027 (paragraph 4.8).

Methodology and sources

The pages used are the Bank of England near-final policy statement of November 16, 2026, chiefly Chapters 1, 3, 4 and 5, and the technical note of the same day, cross-referred as Annex 7. The consultation answered is Ensuring the resilience of CCPs, open from July 18 to November 18, 2025. The EU first tranche is Article 35 of Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) No 153/2013, consolidated on November 29, 2022. The EU second tranche is Article 9(14) of Regulation (EU) 2021/23 as set out in the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) final report of January 31, 2022, ESMA91-372-1706. United States sources are the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) Market Risk Advisory Committee paper of July 13, 2021, the Options Clearing Corporation filing of March 18, 2021, and Press Release 9114-25 of September 4, 2025. Quotations come from Sarah Breeden's speech of May 14, 2025 and Andrew Bailey's lecture of October 24, 2024. The technical note is illustrative rather than the legal rule.

What the near-final rulebook requires on margin, porting and SSITG

SSITG is the CCP's own capital in the default waterfall, beside the mutualised default fund, so the clearing house shares losses with surviving members after the defaulter's margin and the first skin in the game. Paragraph 5.1 records a consulted flat rate of 25% of risk-weighted capital, and paragraph 5.3 cuts that rate to 10% under Rule 2.4(2).

Paragraph 5.5 lets amounts inside the 110% notification threshold count toward the tranche, both skins are available for non-default losses under rule 2.7(2), and section D requires the full amount by April 1, 2028, with replenishment within one month.

Variation margin stays as consulted under paragraphs 3.19 to 3.21, including the CCP's ability to call cash when markets are stressed. Paragraph 3.19, drawing on a subset of the report from the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, the Committee on Payments and Market Infrastructures and the International Organization of Securities Commissions, requires the CCP to weigh the liquidity effect of intraday calls on the member and to explain process and timing.

Second skin in the game (SSITG), in the Bank of England's near-final policy statement of November 16, 2026, is a flat 10% of a CCP's risk-weighted capital requirement under Rule 2.4(2) of the Default Waterfall Part, cut from the 25% rate consulted in 2025. The tranche is consumed pro rata with the mutualised default fund, and paragraph 5.10 allows the loss split after default management ends. On an illustrative £100 million, the Bank's technical note estimates expected loss at £95,000 if that capital sits only after the default fund, and at £295,000 in the central pro-rata case, where Event D has a probability of 99.5%. Applied to a hypothetical 25% single-tranche level of regulatory capital, the same ratios give about 4% to 12%, with a central case near 8%. CCPs must hold the 10% by April 1, 2028 and must replenish within one month.

How the United Kingdom, the European Union and the United States compare

Jurisdiction / regulatorEffective dateScopeKey requirementPenalty / sanction
United Kingdom (Bank of England)November 16, 2026. SSITG from April 1, 2028. Other rules three months after publication (paragraph 1.24).UK CCPs, recognised non-UK CCPs, members and clients (paragraph 1.2).Rule 2.4(2): SSITG at 10% of risk-weighted capital, pro rata with the default fund. Paragraph 3.19 on intraday variation margin.One-month replenishment (paragraph 5.7). Section 138BA permissions under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (paragraph 1.28).
European Union (ESMA and national authorities)Regulation 153/2013. Regulation (EU) 2021/23 of December 16, 2020. ESMA report, January 31, 2022.EU-authorised CCPs under EMIR and the CCP recovery and resolution regulation.Article 35(2): 25% of minimum capital. Article 9(14): 10% to 25% of risk-based capital under Article 16(2), before Annex recovery tools.Article 36: immediate notice and a written replenishment timetable if resources fall below Article 35.
United States (CFTC and clearing-house rules)July 13, 2021 paper. March 18, 2021 filing. September 4, 2025 order.Derivatives clearing organizations, futures commission merchants and swap dealers.July 13, 2021 paper: no agreed statutory percentage. March 18, 2021 filing: 25% of the target capital requirement.$5 million penalty on UBS AG, UBS Financial Services Inc. and UBS Securities LLC, Press Release 9114-25, September 4, 2025.

Sources: Bank of England policy statement, November 16, 2026; Delegated Regulation (EU) No 153/2013; ESMA91-372-1706; CFTC paper, July 13, 2021; OCC filing, March 18, 2021; Press Release 9114-25.

Article 9(14) is a recovery resource inside a 10% to 25% band, and the UK rate is that floor, consumed with the prefunded default fund during default management. The US documents read here fix no statutory second tranche, while the Options Clearing Corporation chose 25% of target capital for its own book. CFTC Letter 26-30 moves the US settlement perimeter, and the Securities and Exchange Commission order on Treasury repo clearing phases a different clearing duty.

For a clearing member, the near-final variation-margin rule is a liquidity and disclosure duty on the CCP, and the porting rule turns on contracts already signed. Paragraph 3.19 requires the CCP to weigh the liquidity effect of intraday collections and payments on the member and to explain process and timing, and paragraph 3.21 leaves that text as consulted, including calls in stress. Paragraph 4.2 removes any duty to tilt default-fund contributions by how portable a client book is. Rule 2.7 requires all reasonable steps to move an omnibus account towards one alternative clearing member designated by every client in that account. Rule 2.9, aligned with UK EMIR Articles 48(5) and 48(6), leaves a receiving member free to refuse a client with no prior contract, so the backup agreement has to exist before default. SSITG remains the CCP's own capital beside that fund and is due on April 1, 2028.

"We should expect CCPs to raise margins in these events. But we also expect CCPs to hold enough margin when markets are calm that the increases are not unmanageable for participants."

— Sarah Breeden, Deputy Governor for Financial Stability, Bank of England (speech at the ISDA Annual General Meeting, May 14, 2025)

Enforcement context for firms in the clearing chain

The near-final statement is a rule-making text and contains no order of its own. The cash penalty on the record read here is the CFTC order announced on September 4, 2025 in Press Release 9114-25, against UBS AG, a registered swap dealer, UBS Financial Services Inc., a registered futures commission merchant, and UBS Securities LLC, registered as a futures commission merchant, commodity pool operator and commodity trading advisor.

The firms failed to supervise trade surveillance diligently from at least 2015 until 2024, with gaps over foreign exchange, metals, rates, credit and exchange-traded derivatives. The civil monetary penalty is $5 million, with a remediation plan and progress reports, and the release gives the press number 9114-25 rather than a docket.

That order sits beside the Bank's porting and variation-margin rules because those rules assume a member can act on what the CCP discloses. Paragraph 4.7 records requests for waivers from capital rules and from anti-money-laundering checks inside a porting window, and leaves those waivers for the 2027 work with the FCA and the PRA.

Breeden's speech of May 14, 2025 names the dash for cash in 2020, commodity stress in early 2022 and gilt dysfunction in autumn 2022, and reports material gaps between members' margin projections and the CCP's figures in the system-wide exploratory scenario. Governor Bailey's lecture of October 24, 2024 says that across the three UK CCPs, 38% of margin came from US clearing members, so a 10% SSITG stands beside a default fund that draws heavily on US members.

What this means for clearing members, clients and compliance teams

Clearing members post margin and default-fund contributions, while SSITG is the CCP's capital under paragraph 5.12, limited to capital, including retained earnings and reserves. Paragraph 5.5 lets the 110% notification resources count toward that tranche, and paragraph 5.15 says the cut from 25% to 10% should reduce how much fresh capital CCPs must raise.

What remains to price is the risk-weighted requirement, the slice labelled SSITG, and the one-month replenishment clock, and paragraph 5.10 means a default-weekend statement of the member's default fund can still be provisional. Clients receive simulators, where they ask and where it is feasible, 24 months after the 2027 instrument commences, with the other new margin rules in paragraph 3.11 at 12 months.

Until those clocks run, paragraph 3.19 is the operative variation-margin text, unscheduled calls in stress stay with the CCP, and override explanations under rule 3.30(1)(c) reach the risk committee after the event. Rule 2.9 means an alternative member accepts a client it has already agreed to accept, and a client whose backup differs from the rest of an omnibus account falls under the reasonable-steps test in rule 2.7.

Know-your-customer work stays in place, templates and capital waivers wait for the 2027 engagement in paragraph 4.7, and the FCA consultation on the Financial Crime Guide is the separate text on how those controls are described. Paragraphs 1.28 to 1.32 intend existing UK EMIR approvals, validations, non-objections and recognitions, including Articles 14 and 25, to continue, so a section 138BA permission is for new activity.

The near-term diary is November 30, 2026 for the Chapter 12 consultation, the first quarter of 2027 for final rules, and April 1, 2028 for SSITG, alongside the FCA consultation on the transaction-reporting switch and the Bank and FCA split over systemic sterling issuers.

"Yes, there is contagion risk if a CCP fails, and especially where it is large in its market, but there are real benefits of scope and scale."

— Andrew Bailey, Governor, Bank of England (Michael D. Gill Memorial Society Lecture, October 24, 2024)

What comes next for the rulebook

The package stays near-final until HM Treasury moves, and the foreword says final rules and final policy are still ahead because they depend on revocation of the relevant UK EMIR provisions. Paragraph 1.24 looks for the first statutory instrument in the fourth quarter of 2026 and for the legislation to be in force by the end of the first quarter of 2027, with the final rulebook at that commencement.

Most rules could then apply three months after the near-final text, or later if the Treasury slips, while SSITG keeps April 1, 2028 in section D and the margin clocks start only at commencement. Porting stays on a 2027 work programme rather than in this instrument, and paragraph 4.8 commits the Bank, with the FCA and the PRA, to engage CCPs, members and end users on steps that make porting more likely.

Paragraph 4.7 records ideas already offered, from the collateral definition in the Settlement Finality Regulations and the Companies Act to a clearing member of last resort, and Chapter 4 adopts none of those items as rules. Chapter 10 offers optional mobilisation under the statement of policy on mobilisation, including a collateral pathway for ineligible collateral up to 1% by post-haircut value inside an overall 2% limit.

Responses on revoking rule 4 of the 2018 instrument are due by November 30, 2026 at FMI-IOREP-CP@bankofengland.co.uk. Chapter 8 lifts model-change thresholds for important components from 5% to 10% and for key resources from 15% to 20%. The Financial Stability Board letter on cross-border vulnerabilities is the frame for paragraph 1.2, which brings recognised non-UK CCPs into the other Parts unless comparable compliance says otherwise.

TL;DR

On November 16, 2026 the Bank of England set second skin in the game at a flat 10% of risk-weighted capital under Rule 2.4(2), down from a consulted 25% and consumed pro rata with the mutualised default fund. CCPs must hold it by April 1, 2028 and replenish it within one month, and resources inside the 110% notification threshold may count. Intraday variation-margin duties stand as consulted. Omnibus porting requires all reasonable steps towards one shared backup member, and a receiver takes a client only under an existing contract. Final rules wait on legislation expected by the end of the first quarter of 2027. Governor Andrew Bailey said on October 24, 2024 that 38% of margin at the three UK CCPs came from US clearing members.

FAQ

What is SSITG in the Bank's near-final CCP rulebook?

SSITG is a second tranche of a CCP's own capital in the default waterfall. Rule 2.4(2) of the Default Waterfall Part, in the November 16, 2026 statement, sets it at 10% of risk-weighted capital, down from a consulted 25%. It is consumed pro rata with the mutualised default fund of non-defaulting members. Only capital counts, including retained earnings and reserves, and amounts inside the 110% notification threshold may be used. After use, including on a non-default loss under rule 2.7(2), the CCP has one month to replenish the tranche.

When must a UK CCP hold the full second tranche?

Section D of the near-final UK Central Counterparties Instrument 2027 sets April 1, 2028 as the date CCPs must meet SSITG. The consultation had proposed 50% at the end of the first year and the full amount at the end of the second. The Bank describes the single date as shorter because the rate is 10% and because 110% resources may count. Most other rules use a minimum of three months from publication of the near-final statement, once the legislation is in force.

What did the Bank decide on variation margin?

Paragraph 3.21 leaves the variation-margin provisions as consulted. Paragraph 3.19 requires the CCP to consider the liquidity effect of intraday collections and payments on the clearing member, and to explain process and timing. The text follows a subset of the BCBS-CPMI-IOSCO practices the statement cites. A request for mandatory risk-committee consultation was met by pointing to the fundamental rules on transparency, and the CCP keeps calls in stress. Paragraph 11.45 amends collateral rule 10.5(2) so the limits refer to margins, including variation margin where appropriate.

Can a clearing member be forced to accept a ported client?

Rule 2.9 requires default procedures to leave an alternative clearing member free of any duty to accept a ported client unless a contract with that client already exists. The Bank aligns the point with UK EMIR Articles 48(5) and 48(6) and expects CCP rulebooks to remain as they stand. Rule 2.7 requires all reasonable steps towards one alternative member designated by every client in an omnibus account. Where the clients share no single designee, the Bank treats a forced transfer as impractical.

How does the EU second-skin band differ from the UK flat rate?

Article 35(2) of Delegated Regulation (EU) No 153/2013 sets the first EU tranche at 25% of minimum capital for the Article 45(4) use. Article 9(14) of Regulation (EU) 2021/23, as ESMA report ESMA91-372-1706 of January 31, 2022 sets it out, requires a further amount of 10% to 25% of risk-based capital under Article 16(2). That further amount is used before specified recovery tools after a default or a non-default event. The UK rule is a flat 10%, the floor of that band, consumed with the prefunded default fund during default management.

Which firms, besides UK CCPs, should read the statement?

Paragraph 1.2 covers UK CCPs and non-UK CCPs that seek or hold recognition to clear for UK members or at UK trading venues. Systemic overseas CCPs follow the other Parts unless a comparable-compliance permission modifies that duty. Non-systemic overseas CCPs have a smaller notification set under the Overseas Part. Clearing members, prospective members, clients and trade bodies are addressed as well. Recognitions under UK EMIR Articles 14 and 25 are intended to carry on, so the practical task is to map which Parts apply.

This article is informational analysis only and does not constitute legal, regulatory, tax, or investment advice. Regulatory frameworks change frequently and interpretation depends on facts and circumstances; primary documents and official regulator guidance always supersede summaries. Firms should consult qualified legal counsel and their relevant supervisory authority before taking any action based on the analysis above.

Reporting by Rick Steves. Filed 20 November 2026, 09:26 GMT.

Senior Reporter, Regulation and Fintech

Rick Steves has seen business and economics through many lenses. He joined the financial services industry in 2009, and has been a financial journalist since 2011.

All 2,133 stories by Rick Steves