The Industry Spread

Follow

XFacebookLinkedIn

Regulation

Why Custodia leaves the Fed master-account test standing

The Supreme Court left Custodia's master-account loss in place, so eligibility under the Federal Reserve Act still leaves a Reserve Bank free to refuse.

Why Custodia leaves the Fed master-account test standing

The Supreme Court's denial of review in Custodia Bank versus the Federal Reserve Board of Governors, docket 26-62, leaves standing a Tenth Circuit reading under which legal eligibility for a master account does not compel a Reserve Bank to open one.

On November 16, 2026, the order list headed 610 US placed docket 26-62 under certiorari denied, and the public docket records "Petition DENIED," with no opinion in the case on that day's page of opinions relating to orders. Left in place is the Tenth Circuit judgment of October 31, 2025, in docket 24-8024, treating section 342 ("may receive") as discretion and section 248a(c)(2) ("shall be available") as a pricing rule. The working test, for Custodia and for later applicants, remains the Board's Account Access Guidelines.

Key facts

  • November 16, 2026: certiorari denied in docket 26-62, filed July 10, 2026 and distributed for the November 13, 2026 conference (Supreme Court docket).
  • October 31, 2025: the Tenth Circuit affirmed docket 24-8024. Rehearing was denied on March 13, 2026. The district case, 1:22-cv-00125-SWS, is reported at 728 F Supp 3d 1227 (D Wyo 2024).
  • Custodia applied to the Kansas City Reserve Bank in October 2020, heard "no showstoppers" in January 2021, and was denied in January 2023, the day the Board also denied membership (Tenth Circuit opinion).
  • Account Access Guidelines took effect on August 19, 2022, at 87 FR 51099. The court placed Custodia in Tier 3, which "generally receive[s] the strictest level of review."
  • Wyoming special purpose depository institutions, created in 2019, may not lend, and dollar deposits must be 100% backed by liquid assets (Wyoming Statutes sections 13-12-103 and 13-12-105, as the court recited).
  • July 1, 2024: a $43 million civil money penalty against Silvergate for anti-money laundering (AML) monitoring failures. Board and California penalties together totalled $63 million (Board release).
  • May 26, 2026: Payment Account proposal at 91 FR 30627, with comments closed on July 27, 2026 and a Tier 3 pause the notice expected to end on or before December 31, 2026.

Methodology and sources

The record runs from the Federal Reserve Act of 1913 and the Monetary Control Act of 1980 to the November 16, 2026 order list. Primary documents are the docket in 26-62, the order list and the Tenth Circuit opinion. Rules cited are the Guidelines at 87 FR 51099, the December 12, 2024 clarification at 89 FR 100495 and the Payment Account proposal at 91 FR 30627, with Bank of England rules on Real-Time Gross Settlement (RTGS), Guideline (EU) 2022/912 and Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) terms for MEPS+. Enforcement is the Board's Silvergate orders.

A denial of certiorari publishes no vote and does not adopt the court of appeals' reading as a Supreme Court holding. Where the majority dates the Kansas City denial to January 2023 and the dissent dates the letter differently, this account follows the majority. Scope is who may hold a central-bank settlement account in the United States, the United Kingdom, the euro area and Singapore.

What section 342 and section 248a actually do

A master account is a depository institution's balance at a Reserve Bank, and the Tenth Circuit noted that no statute uses the phrase. Wire transfer and settlement run through that record or through a correspondent that already has one. Custodia, founded in 2020 and chartered in Wyoming, asked the court to treat eligibility as a right to the account.

Judge David Ebel wrote for the court, with Judge Timothy Tymkovich dissenting. Section 342 (12 USC section 342) says a Reserve Bank "may receive" deposits. Section 248a(c)(2), from the Monetary Control Act of 1980, says covered services "shall be available" to nonmembers and "shall be priced" on the member schedule. Section 248c, the 2022 Toomey Amendment, requires a public database of requests marked approved, rejected, pending or withdrawn.

The court held that "may receive" is discretionary, and that "shall be available" is a pricing principle rather than an order to bank every eligible firm. Agreeing with the district court at 728 F Supp 3d at 1245, it held that the statutes give Custodia no automatic entitlement.

A Federal Reserve master account is the deposit relationship through which an eligible institution settles in central-bank money, and the Tenth Circuit has held that eligibility starts the review rather than ending it. Section 342 of the Federal Reserve Act, 12 USC section 342, authorises a Reserve Bank to receive deposits with the verb "may." Section 248a(c)(2), from the Monetary Control Act of 1980, says covered services "shall be available" to nonmember depository institutions at the member-bank fee schedule. In its October 31, 2025 judgment, docket 24-8024, the court treated the second provision as a pricing principle and the first as discretion to refuse one applicant. The opinion records statutory eligibility, a January 2021 note of "no showstoppers," and a January 2023 denial under the Account Access Guidelines, effective August 19, 2022 (87 FR 51099). On November 16, 2026 the Supreme Court denied review in docket 26-62, leaving that judgment in place for these parties.

Tier 1, federally insured firms, generally draws a lighter review, and Tier 2 covers uninsured firms under federal prudential supervision. Tier 3, where the court placed Custodia, has neither, and it "generally receive[s] the strictest level of review." The denial letter called the novel and "unprecedented" model, "narrowly focused on crypto-asset activities," a source of risks "highly likely [to be] inconsistent with safe and sound banking practices." Membership, refused the same day, was not on appeal, and mandamus under 28 USC section 1361 fell away once discretion was found.

How the United States, Britain and the euro area gate payment accounts

Four regimes decide who may hold a settlement account and who may refuse one.

Jurisdiction / RegulatorEffective dateScopeKey requirementPenalty / sanction
United States — Federal Reserve August 19, 2022 (87 FR 51099); clarified December 12, 2024 Tier 3 lacks federal insurance and federal prudential supervision Section 342 discretionary; section 248a(c)(2) a pricing rule (October 31, 2025) Custodia denied January 2023; Silvergate $43 million on July 1, 2024
United Kingdom — Bank of England and the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) July 19, 2017 opening of RTGS accounts to non-bank payment firms FCA-authorised e-money and payment institutions; small registered firms excluded Settlement account only, 2017 safeguarding rules, and a section 166 review first Access remains at the Bank's sole discretion, so refusal is the sanction
Euro area — European Central Bank (ECB) and national central banks Guideline (EU) 2022/912, February 24, 2022; TARGET from November 21, 2022 Article 4 on-request class: Union or EEA credit institutions Every other body enters only by national-central-bank discretion Exclusion once the participant misses the Article 4 access criteria
Singapore — MAS, MEPS+ Service Agreement of October 13, 2019; MAS Act section 29A November 2024: 60 participants (MAS, 54 banks, one finance company, four infrastructures) Section 29A approval, a current licence and SWIFT connectivity No direct participation without section 29A approval

Sources: 87 FR 51099; Tenth Circuit opinion; Bank of England non-bank access guide; Guideline (EU) 2022/912; MEPS+ Service Agreement; last updated November 17, 2026.

The United States, the United Kingdom and the euro area each keep a gate in front of settlement in central-bank money. Under 12 USC section 342 a Reserve Bank may receive deposits, and the Tenth Circuit's October 31, 2025 judgment in docket 24-8024 holds that the verb stays permissive for a legally eligible nonmember, while the Account Access Guidelines of August 19, 2022 (87 FR 51099) place an uninsured, non-federally supervised firm such as Custodia in Tier 3. Since July 19, 2017 the Bank of England has allowed FCA-authorised electronic money institutions and payment institutions to apply for an RTGS settlement account, stating that access remains at the Bank's sole discretion and that these firms receive no reserves account. Guideline (EU) 2022/912, Annex I, Part I, Article 4, makes Union or European Economic Area credit institutions eligible for TARGET on request and leaves every other category to the national central bank.

A firm can clear one statute's eligibility test and still fail the risk review the account-holding central bank kept. The draft MAS power over a designated foreign stablecoin is a token gate, and section 29A remains the settlement-account test.

"The new guidelines provide a consistent and transparent process to evaluate requests for Federal Reserve accounts and access to payment services in order to support a safe, inclusive, and innovative payment system."

— Lael Brainard, Vice Chair, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (Federal Reserve Board, August 15, 2022)

That August 15, 2022 sentence describes a process and promises no particular account, the distinction the Tenth Circuit enforced and the November 16, 2026 order list left in place.

The Silvergate penalty and the risk screen behind a denial

Custodia sued to compel an account it had never held. Silvergate held one, took a large book of digital-asset deposits, and then answered for how it monitored that book. The records answer different questions, and a compliance programme that collapses them will miss both.

On June 1, 2023 the Board announced a consent cease-and-desist order, with California's Department of Financial Protection and Innovation, for the self-liquidation Silvergate had announced on March 8, 2023. The order channelled the wind-down and assessed no penalty. On July 1, 2024 the Board announced $43 million for AML monitoring failures and said penalties with the state totalled $63 million. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) announced a further penalty with no dollar figure in the Board's release. The Office of Inspector General, on September 27, 2023, recorded assets above $16 billion in 2021 and said examiners could have acted sooner.

That loss is what the Guidelines tell a Reserve Bank to weigh before an account exists. The December 12, 2024 clarification, 89 FR 100495, lists risk to the Reserve Bank, the payment system, financial stability, illicit finance and monetary-policy implementation. On the Silvergate record, holding a master account did not itself produce the monitoring the Bank Secrecy Act requires.

The Tenth Circuit set the holding beside Banco San Juan Internacional versus the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, 762 F Supp 3d 247, and PayServices Bank versus the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, 2024 WL 1347094 (D Idaho, March 30, 2024), both trial judgments rather than a Supreme Court rule for every circuit. Wyoming's no-lending rule and 100% liquid reserve were in the record and did not decide it. The New York and Wyoming oversight memorandum compares firms that those states already license and leaves section 342 untouched.

What the standing test means for banks and compliance teams

A bank that already holds a master account will feel the judgment in its correspondent book. After November 16, 2026 a Tier 3 customer cannot describe a direct account as something this statute will shortly compel, while the Tenth Circuit's judgment remains the last word in its own case, so exit terms belong in the resolution pack.

An exchange, custodian or payments firm that wants the account has the opinion's sequence as its manual. Kansas City confirmed eligibility in January 2021 and denied the application in January 2023, so eligibility started no ministerial clock.

Fund managers placing client money at a chartered digital-asset bank have a disclosure point. The bank can be fully reserved under Wyoming law and still able to settle only through another institution, a concentration separate from the stablecoin capital treatment on Docket R-1899.

One memorandum should identify the paragraph of 12 USC section 461(b) relied on for deposits other than trust funds, and a second should map insurance and any federal supervisor onto the tiers in 87 FR 51099. A third should set illicit-finance controls beside the Silvergate orders, and a fourth should set out the correspondent-exit plan.

"We are bound by the ordinary language of the statute and, in my view, shall means shall. Section § 248a(c)(2) mandates access to the Fed's payment services for all nonmember depository institutions."

— Timothy M Tymkovich, Circuit Judge, United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, dissenting (Tenth Circuit opinion, docket 24-8024)

Judge Tymkovich's dissent would treat "shall" in section 248a(c)(2) as a mandate mandamus could enforce, and it remains a dissent. Firms that prefer that reading still operate under the majority unless another court of appeals, or Congress, takes the question up.

What remains open after the order list

The Kansas City denial stands, the Tenth Circuit's judgment stands, and this petition will not be heard. Another applicant, in another circuit, can still argue for Judge Tymkovich's reading of section 248a(c)(2). The Board can still open a master account for a Tier 3 firm whose risk file it accepts.

The live text is the Payment Account proposal of May 26, 2026, at 91 FR 30627, with comments closed on July 27, 2026. The closing balance would not exceed $1 billion, interest would be withheld under a companion change to Regulation D, and the holder would get neither discount-window access under Regulation A nor intraday credit. Services would be Fedwire Funds, FedNow, the National Settlement Service and Fedwire Securities free of payment. The holder could not act as a correspondent or pair it with a master account, and a Tier 2 or Tier 3 file would generally be finished within 90 calendar days.

The notice expected the Tier 3 pause to end on or before December 31, 2026, an expectation in a proposal rather than a statutory deadline, and it grants Custodia no account. The GENIUS Act's treatment of foreign issuers and the Bank of England's proposed sterling-stablecoin holding cap allocate who may issue a token and how large the stock may grow, and neither amends section 342. The regulation desk keeps issuer rules and this access rule apart, because a charter, a licence and an account remain three separate permissions.

TL;DR

On November 16, 2026 the Supreme Court denied Custodia Bank's petition in docket 26-62 and left the Tenth Circuit's October 31, 2025 judgment in place. That judgment treats 12 USC section 342, under which a Reserve Bank "may receive" deposits, as discretion to refuse a master account to a legally eligible applicant, and treats 12 USC section 248a(c)(2) as a pricing rule. Custodia, a Wyoming special purpose depository institution, applied in October 2020 and was denied in January 2023 under Guidelines effective August 19, 2022. The order binds these parties and installs no Supreme Court holding for other circuits. The risk screen is concrete: on July 1, 2024 the Board announced a $43 million penalty against Silvergate for AML monitoring failures. A Payment Account proposed on May 26, 2026 would narrow access rather than turn eligibility into a right.

FAQ

What did the Supreme Court decide in Custodia's master-account case?

The Court decided not to hear the case. The order list for Monday, November 16, 2026 places docket 26-62 under certiorari denied, and the docket entry reads "Petition DENIED." No opinion accompanied the denial, so the order does not adopt the Tenth Circuit's reading as a Supreme Court holding. The judgment of October 31, 2025, after rehearing was denied on March 13, 2026, binds these parties.

What is a Federal Reserve master account?

A master account is the deposit relationship an eligible institution holds at a regional Reserve Bank and the record through which it uses Federal Reserve payment services. The statutes never use that phrase. Authority sits in 12 USC section 342, which says a Reserve Bank "may receive" deposits, and without the account the firm settles through a correspondent. Custodia applied in Kansas City in October 2020 and was denied in January 2023.

Does a Wyoming special purpose charter guarantee an account?

The Tenth Circuit held that the Wyoming charter creates eligibility and then stops. Special purpose depository institutions, created in 2019, may take dollar deposits, may not make loans, and must keep those deposits 100% backed by liquid assets under Wyoming Statutes sections 13-12-103 and 13-12-105. The court recorded that Custodia was eligible. On its reading of section 342, eligibility did not require the Reserve Bank to open the account.

How do the Account Access Guidelines sort applicants?

The Guidelines took effect on August 19, 2022, at 87 FR 51099, Docket OP-1747, and sort legally eligible applicants by risk to the Reserve Bank, the payment system, stability, illicit finance and monetary policy. Federally insured institutions are Tier 1. Uninsured institutions under federal prudential supervision are Tier 2. Firms with neither federal insurance nor federal supervision are Tier 3 and generally receive the strictest review. The Tenth Circuit recorded Custodia in Tier 3.

How does Britain's RTGS access differ from a master account?

Since July 19, 2017 an electronic money institution or payment institution authorised by the FCA may apply for an RTGS settlement account. These firms cannot hold a reserves account, because they sit outside the Sterling Monetary Framework, and access remains at the Bank of England's sole discretion. Client funds must be safeguarded under the Payment Services Regulations 2017. An FCA non-objection, including a section 166 review, comes before the Bank decides.

Would the proposed Payment Account have given Custodia what it sought?

The May 26, 2026 proposal, 91 FR 30627, describes a narrower account than the master account Custodia sought. As proposed, it would cap the closing balance at no more than $1 billion, pay no interest and offer neither discount-window nor intraday credit. The holder could not act as a correspondent or keep it beside a master account, and the Board wrote that it should not signal a later master account. The notice grants Custodia neither kind of account.

This article is informational analysis only and does not constitute legal, regulatory, tax, or investment advice. Regulatory frameworks change frequently and interpretation depends on facts and circumstances; primary documents and official regulator guidance always supersede summaries. Firms should consult qualified legal counsel and their relevant supervisory authority before taking any action based on the analysis above.

Reporting by Rick Steves. Filed 17 November 2026, 08:02 GMT.

Senior Reporter, Regulation and Fintech

Rick Steves has seen business and economics through many lenses. He joined the financial services industry in 2009, and has been a financial journalist since 2011.

All 2,117 stories by Rick Steves