The Industry Spread

Follow

XFacebookLinkedIn

Regulation

FCA CP26/40 would lift performance fees from the charge cap

CP26/40 would place specified performance fees outside the 0.75% workplace default charge cap, and the exemption is still only a consultation proposal.

FCA CP26/40 would lift performance fees from the charge cap

Consultation Paper CP26/40 would let specified performance fees sit outside the 0.75% charge cap on workplace default pensions run by Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) firms, aligning contract-based schemes with the trust-based exclusion in force since April 6, 2023, while the text remains a proposal until final rules expected in summer 2027.

Regulation 6(2) of the Occupational Pension Schemes (Charges and Governance) Regulations 2015, and Conduct of Business Sourcebook (COBS) 19.6.4R and COBS 19.6.6R, set that 0.75% ceiling for default funds. CP26/40, opened on November 12, 2026, would add a permissive exemption for qualifying performance-based fees and a narrower exclusion for most physical-asset holding costs, with responses due on January 14, 2027.

Key facts

  • CP26/40 opened on November 12, 2026, comments close on January 14, 2027, and final rules are expected in summer 2027 (consultation page and paragraph 1.14).
  • The single-charge cap is 0.75% a year under regulation 6(2) of Statutory Instrument 2015/879 and, for contract-based defaults, COBS 19.6.
  • Specified performance-based fees left the trust-based definition of charges on April 6, 2023, under SI 2023/399.
  • The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) Pension Provider Survey 2024-2025, at paragraph 2.11, reports median charges of 0.32% multi-employer and 0.24% single-employer.
  • Annex 2, Table 1 puts central 10-year present values at £14,315 million of benefits, £5,531 million of costs and £8,784 million of net value.
  • The May 2025 Mansion House Accord, in the cost benefit analysis, has 17 signatories and about £206 billion of contract-based accumulation defaults.
  • On November 18, 2019 the FCA fined Henderson Investment Funds Limited £1,867,900 under section 206 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000.

Methodology and sources

Primary documents carry the account: CP26/40, its Appendix 1 draft instrument and Annex 2, the technical annex, and the FCA press release of the same day. Trust-side law is the 2015 charges regulations, the 2023 amending regulations and the 2021 physical-asset regulations, plus the statutory guidance on performance-based fees and the charge cap. The Henderson final notice is the enforcement example, and valuation context is the FCA's multi-firm review of private market valuation practices of March 5, 2025. Comparators are the Pan-European Personal Pension Product regulation and the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974. The window runs from the 2015 cap through November 16, 2026, and the cost benefit figures are the FCA's model rather than observed member outcomes.

What the draft exemption actually requires

The cap was built for a default the employer chooses. Regulation 6 sets the trust-based limits, with a single charge of 0.75% a year of rights in the default, and combination structures also exist, and the FCA copied that policy into COBS 19.6. An administration charge is a sum taken from rights or gains for a purpose other than buying benefits, transaction costs already sit outside that sum, and performance fees, including carried interest, still sit inside it for contract-based defaults.

A qualifying performance-based fee, under draft COBS 19.6B, can leave the workplace default cap only when two conditions are both met. Draft COBS 19.6B.5R requires the fee to be calculated only by reference to an increase in investment performance, and the proposed glossary would treat carried interest and other profit-sharing arrangements as performance-based fees where that test is met. Draft COBS 19.6B.6R requires terms, fixed before the operator invests, covering the hurdle or amount performance must beat, the measurement period, the payment point, a device that dampens short-term swings, and a duty on the manager to provide fee information on request. CP26/40, published on November 12, 2026, says a fee that misses either condition ordinarily stays an administration charge inside the 0.75% limits in COBS 19.6.4R and COBS 19.6.6R. The exemption would be permissive, and an operator could rely on it only together with the draft valuation rule in COBS 19.6B.15R.

The hurdle in draft COBS 19.6B.6R(3) must clear a relevant benchmark between valuation points or across a closed-end life, and the draft allows payment other than cash. Draft COBS 19.6B.10G lists a high-water mark, returned capital, clawback, escrow or a fee cap as the stabiliser, with later review under draft COBS 19.6B.12R, and draft COBS 19.6B.15R would stop an investment that lacks valuation policies, including on continuation-vehicle conflicts.

The information duty in draft COBS 19.6B.6R(2)(e) makes look-through, including in a fund of funds, a condition of the exemption, going beyond the pre-agreed rate, period and short-term term in SI 2023/399. The paper's illustrations, rather than proposed caps, include a 2% and 20% closed-end fee. Since October 1, 2021, SI 2021/1070 has taken physical-asset holding costs, valuation fees included, out of trust-based charges, while the FCA draft would keep valuation fees inside the cap.

Jurisdiction / RegulatorEffective dateScopeKey requirementPenalty / sanction
United Kingdom, FCA (contract-based)Opened November 12, 2026; final rules expected summer 2027.Operators of qualifying-scheme default arrangements.Draft COBS 19.6B.5R and 19.6B.6R would place a qualifying fee outside the 0.75% cap in COBS 19.6.FSMA 2000 section 206 financial penalty, with no statutory maximum, plus section 205 public censure.
United Kingdom, DWP and The Pensions RegulatorExclusion from April 6, 2023 (SI 2023/399). Cap since 2015 (SI 2015/879). Physical assets from October 1, 2021.Trustees of occupational defined-contribution defaults.Regulation 6(2) caps a single charge at 0.75% a year, with pre-agreed performance-based fees outside that sum.Pensions Act 1995 section 10: up to £5,000 for an individual and £50,000 otherwise.
European Union, Basic PEPPRegulation (EU) 2019/1238 has applied since March 22, 2022.Providers of a Basic Pan-European Personal Pension Product.Article 45 caps Basic PEPP costs and fees at 1% of accumulated capital a year.Article 67: Member State penalties that are effective, proportionate and dissuasive.
United States, Department of LaborSection 404(a)(1) since 1975. Fee disclosure in 29 CFR 2550.404a-5.Fiduciaries of ERISA defined-contribution plans.No 0.75% cap. Section 404(a)(1) requires prudence; 29 CFR 2550.404a-5 sets fee content.Section 502(l) of ERISA sets a civil penalty equal to 20% of the applicable recovery amount.

Sources: CP26/40; SI 2015/879; SI 2023/399; SI 2021/1070; Regulation (EU) 2019/1238 Articles 45 and 67; ERISA sections 404(a)(1) and 502(l); Pensions Act 1995 section 10; FSMA 2000 sections 205 and 206, last checked on November 16, 2026.

How four fee regimes treat a performance fee

Workplace default charge caps already diverge inside the United Kingdom, and CP26/40 is a proposal to narrow that split. Trust-based occupational schemes have, since April 6, 2023, been able to leave specified performance-based fees out of the charges that count towards the 0.75% cap in regulation 6(2) of the Occupational Pension Schemes (Charges and Governance) Regulations 2015, after the 2023 amending regulations. Contract-based schemes supervised by the Financial Conduct Authority still count those fees inside an equivalent 0.75% administration-charge cap. The Basic Pan-European Personal Pension Product uses a different test: Article 45 of Regulation (EU) 2019/1238 limits costs and fees on the Basic PEPP to 1% of accumulated capital a year, and that regulation has applied since March 22, 2022. United States defined-contribution plans have no matching percentage cap. Fiduciaries must act prudently under section 404(a)(1) of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, and section 502(l) sets a civil penalty equal to 20% of the applicable recovery amount.

A provider running a master trust and a contract-based scheme can already place a performance-fee sleeve on the trust side, because a strong contract-side year can push administration charges through 0.75%. The May 2025 Accord aim, 10% of main defaults in private markets by 2030 with at least 5% in the UK, therefore meets a tighter test on the contract-based book. Retail access is handled on a different track, which is why FS26/3 keeps a tight line on high-risk retail investment access while this consultation would open a private-market fee path in a default, resembling the way the Bank of England and the FCA divide systemic sterling issuers.

"People's pension savings should work hard for them. We want providers to have greater choice over how they invest for the long term where this can deliver better outcomes for savers. But greater flexibility is not a licence to charge more. Any higher charges must be justified by additional value, with firms carefully weighing returns, risks and costs when deciding what is in savers' best interests."

— Therese Chambers, executive director of enforcement and market integrity, Financial Conduct Authority (FCA press release, November 12, 2026)

Where fees have already outrun the service

The closest published FCA case is a retail-fund conduct notice for a fee that stayed high after the work changed. On November 18, 2019 the FCA issued a final notice to Henderson Investment Funds Limited, firm reference 121859, and imposed £1,867,900 under section 206 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000. The products were the Henderson Japan Enhanced Equity Fund and the Henderson North American Enhanced Equity Fund.

In November 2011 the appointed manager cut active management on those funds sharply. Institutional investors were told and offered management without charge. Retail investors stayed on the old fee, and the prospectus stayed as it was. From November 2011 to August 2016 the funds behaved more like trackers, and affected investors paid £1,784,465.32 more than a passive Henderson index fund would have charged. Principle 6 was breached from November 2011 to August 2016, and Principle 3 from November 2011 to March 2017, because the decision bypassed both a governing committee and compliance.

A default member pays a fee without having hired the manager, and a fee struck off an appraisal lets the manager who is paid on the number influence the number, the conflict the 2025 review described in continuation vehicles. Draft COBS 19.6B.15R would make the pension operator test valuation governance before the allocation, the same judgement problem the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) sets out in REP 842. Henderson concerned a fixed fee that became too rich for a passive book, and the sanction was a conduct penalty rather than restitution of the £1,784,465.32 gap.

What this means for operators, managers and savers

Draft COBS 19.6B would bind the operator of a qualifying scheme, the FCA firm running a contract-based workplace pension, and would leave trustee boards on the DWP rulebook unless ministers amend it after the shared evidence in chapter eight. Retail foreign-exchange brokers, trading venues and crypto-asset service providers sit outside that operator definition, so the draft speaks to carry inside a default rather than to those firms' own permissions. Employers, administrators, consumer groups and default members are the other readers named on the consultation page.

An operator that wanted the exemption would document, before investing, the hurdle, the period, the payment terms, the stabiliser and an information right reaching a fund of funds. Draft COBS 19.6B.14G puts mandates without a performance fee in the Consumer Duty comparison set, and Independent Governance Committees (IGCs) would still see the fee inside value for money. Compliance teams file that valuation due diligence with the allocation, since draft COBS 19.6B.15R stops an investment that lacks it. Administrators producing member numbers, the work behind pension-office paperwork tools, would track accruals and high-water marks with the ongoing charge.

Fund managers sit outside the operator definition, yet the holding stays inside the cap where they withhold the information duty or the valuation governance the draft requires. CP26/28, and the International Organization of Securities Commissions valuation report, stay a wider wholesale baseline. COBS 19.8 already tells UK managers to give providers charge information, and the draft would extend that duty to performance fees. Regulation 1(5) of SI 2023/399 drops the old performance-fee definition only on April 5, 2028, and schemes already smoothing those fees keep the smoothing until the earlier of a five-year run-off and that date.

"We’ve been working, as you know, in partnership with industry, backing really ambitious initiatives such as the Mansion House Accord, delivering major reforms through the Pension Schemes Act to drive that consolidation in the sector, supporting long-term investment and delivering better outcomes for savers."

— The Rt Hon Lucy Rigby KC MP, economic secretary to the Treasury, HM Treasury (speech at UK Private Capital, September 10, 2026)

What stays open until summer rules

CP26/40 leaves the handbook as it stands. The draft instrument is the Conduct of Business (Pension Schemes: Performance-Based Fees and Charge Cap) Instrument 202X, year and board date blank, and comments are due on January 14, 2027 by the online form or to cp26-40@fca.org.uk for Felix Grenfell Bozek. Final rules are placed in summer 2027 by both the paper and the press release, after which any trust-side amendment stays a case-by-case decision for DWP and The Pensions Regulator.

Question seven asks whether the information duty will shut out funds an operator cannot renegotiate, questions 19 and 20 test keeping physical-asset valuation fees inside the cap, and questions 15 and 16 ask whether fair allocation between joiners and leavers can rest on guidance. Question five opens the wider argument about the cap as multi-employer schemes consolidate towards the £25 billion scale the cost benefit analysis cites for 2030.

Annex 2 puts central benefits at £14,315 million and costs at £5,531 million, a net present value of £8,784 million over 10 years, a 2.1% lift in median net returns, with certainty-equivalent annual returns moving from 8.45% to 8.68%. About £40 million of the cost is implementation, on a modelled 2% fee and 20% carry over an 8% hurdle. At the fifth percentile, year-10 portfolio value is £306.0 billion against a £299.9 billion baseline, and the annex records that some savers could still be worse off, and the September 10, 2026 speech flagged private-credit links with banks and insurers.

Trust-based schemes can keep using the 2023 exclusion where the statute and the statutory guidance are met, while contract-based operators remain on today's COBS 19.6 until a made instrument replaces the blank-year draft. Value-for-money rules expected in the first half of 2027 may arrive beside that instrument, and until the instrument is made the contract-based default still counts the carry.

TL;DR

CP26/40 would allow specified performance fees to sit outside the 0.75% administration-charge cap on default funds in workplace pensions run by FCA-authorised operators. The trust-based exclusion has applied since April 6, 2023; the contract-based version is still a consultation, opened on November 12, 2026, with responses due on January 14, 2027 and final rules expected in summer 2027. A fee qualifies only if it is calculated solely on an increase in investment performance and the hurdle, period, payment terms, short-term stabiliser and information duty were agreed before the investment. The FCA’s cost benefit analysis puts central present-value benefits at £14,315 million and costs at £5,531 million over 10 years, an NPV of £8,784 million, assuming private-market exposure rises among Mansion House Accord signatories. Savers in defaults would depend on operators and committees to test whether the extra fee buys value.

FAQ

What is the workplace pensions charge cap?

The charge cap limits administration charges in a default used for automatic enrolment. Regulation 6(2) of the Occupational Pension Schemes (Charges and Governance) Regulations 2015 sets the single-charge limit at 0.75% a year of the member's rights, and COBS 19.6.4R and COBS 19.6.6R apply that ceiling to contract-based qualifying schemes. CP26/40 would add qualifying performance-based fees and most physical-asset holding costs to the same outside list.

Who would CP26/40 affect?

Draft COBS 19.6B would apply to the operator of a qualifying scheme, the FCA firm running a contract-based workplace pension used for automatic enrolment. Independent Governance Committees would keep performance fees in the value-for-money remit, and private-asset managers would have to accept an information duty before a fee could qualify. Employers, administrators, trustees and default members are named on the consultation page.

Which fees could leave the cap?

Only a qualifying performance-based fee leaves the cap. It must be calculated solely on an increase in investment performance, carried interest included, and the hurdle, period, payment terms, short-term stabiliser and information duty must have been fixed before the investment. A flat management fee stays inside the 0.75% sum, as does a performance fee whose advance terms miss those points. Physical-asset valuation fees stay inside the FCA cap.

Can contract-based schemes use the exemption today?

Trust-based schemes can use the exemption where the 2023 definition and the statutory guidance are met. That exclusion has been in force since April 6, 2023. The contract-based text is still a consultation. CP26/40 opened on November 12, 2026 with a blank instrument year, comments run to January 14, 2027, and final rules are expected in summer 2027. Until a made instrument lands, COBS 19.6 still counts the performance fee towards the 0.75% cap.

How does the FCA draft differ from the DWP rules?

Both texts recognise a fee calculated only on investment performance, with a pre-agreed hurdle or amount, a period and a short-term stabiliser, and both keep 0.75% for every other administration charge. The FCA draft adds an information duty as a condition of the exemption, stops the investment where valuation governance is missing, and keeps physical-asset valuation fees inside the cap. Commercial terms and fair allocation sit on the Consumer Duty and on guidance while the consultation is open.

Would value for money still count an exempt fee?

Value for money would still count the fee. Performance fees already sit in the charges Independent Governance Committees assess, and CP26/40 would keep them there through COBS 19.5 after they leave the 0.75% calculation. A separate value-for-money framework, with final rules expected in the first half of 2027, is written to do the same. A fee outside the cap would remain a figure the committee has to explain to members.

This article is informational analysis only and does not constitute legal, regulatory, tax, or investment advice. Regulatory frameworks change frequently and interpretation depends on facts and circumstances; primary documents and official regulator guidance always supersede summaries. Firms should consult qualified legal counsel and their relevant supervisory authority before taking any action based on the analysis above.

Reporting by Rick Steves. Filed 16 November 2026, 16:07 GMT.

Senior Reporter, Regulation and Fintech

Rick Steves has seen business and economics through many lenses. He joined the financial services industry in 2009, and has been a financial journalist since 2011.

All 2,116 stories by Rick Steves