• Industry Directory

The Industry Spread

News and information for the global trading industry

  • INDUSTRY NEWS
  • REGULATORY ANNOUNCEMENTS
  • CENTRAL BANK ANNOUNCEMENTS
  • Market News
  • INDUSTRY INSIGHTS
  • INDUSTRY JOBS
  • SEARCH
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • More Infomation
    • About us
    • Our Market News Team
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Cookies Policy
    • Disclaimer
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
You are here: Home / Archives for ATS

Equity Market Innovation Leads to Venue Proliferation

May 25, 2018 by Ivy Schmerken Leave a Comment Filed Under: Thought Leadership, Thought Leadership Articles Tagged: ATS, Buy Side, dark pool, Equity Market, equity trading, FINRA, Imperative Execution, Intelligent Cross, Long Term Stock Exchange, Luminex Trading, M-ELO, NASDAQ, Stock Exchange, trading strategies, trading system, Venue Proliferation

Several startups are planning to launch either new venues or order types, and even listing standards, to solve problems in US equity trading.

At last month’s SIFMA Equity Market Structure conference, executives with the following three startups and one established exchange discussed their particular market innovations and how each one fits into the existing equity market structure.

  • Imperative Execution is on the brink of launching a dark pool to actively solve the problem of minimizing market impact.
  • Nasdaq Stock Market introduced a new order type to help institutions gather more liquidity.
  • Luminex Trading & Analytics is running a buy-side only block execution facility, which has gained traction over the past three years.
  • Long Term Stock Exchange is in registration to become a stock exchange to help companies access the public markets and discourage short-term trading.

But each of these venues is entering a complicated marketplace. With 12 exchanges and more than 30 ATSs, any new entrant is facing hurdles of convincing buy-side and sell-side firms to connect to their venues to send order flow.

“Market impact is a problem that a significant segment of the market cares about across the board,” said Roman Ginis, founder and CEO of Imperative Execution, a startup based in Stamford, Conn., which is preparing to launch a dark pool known as Intelligent Cross in May.  “The market makers care about this, the long-onlys care and the strategy funds care, even though they each have different holding periods,” said Ginis.

Roman Ginis

Roman Ginis

“Instead of looking for a silver bullet that solves the problem in the marketplace, we look at it as an optimization problem,” said Ginis, who has a PhD in computer science from the California Institute of Technology and is a former quantitative trader at Cubist Systematic Strategies, a business of Point72 Asset Management. Ginis said he spent many years designing algorithms for different strategies.

The startup is seeded by Steve Cohen’s Point 72 Ventures arm to combat slippage associated with certain high frequency trading strategies, as first reported in The Wall Street Journal in Steven Cohen Targets High-Frequency Trading with ‘Dark Pool’ Venture. However, Ginis said the problem is not specific to HFT and is much broader.

“The problem is we have a market great for small orders. The US market is deep and fast and highly liquid for retail.  We don’t have an efficient market for those who want to trade a few thousand shares,” said Ginis. “This is why all the algorithmic desks exist,” he said. We built this platform to be additive to everyone’s algorithm that want to execute over time,” he said.

Unlike other ATSs, it will not work “parent” orders; instead, it will only see the “child orders” that are executed through algorithms, he said. About 80% of the market is algorithms working orders in the market.

Intelligent Cross will run a midpoint cross whose objective is to get the market impact immediately after the print as close to zero as possible, said Ginis.

Need for Differentiation

What sets the dark pool apart from other rivals is that it uses machine learning to optimize its matching engine’s decision of when to trade based on the liquidity of each stock.

Rather than design a continuous trading system, Intelligent Cross is a venue that optimizes at discrete times. It will measure its own performance, learn from empirical data and “recalibrate” the match time for each stock, said Ginis.

As a near continuous match, it matches every couple of milliseconds, which is different for every stock based on its liquidity. To find the best time to trade, the ATS measures the market response typically 5-10 milliseconds after its own print. This is typical since algorithms also measure the book before and after, and know exactly how much slippage they received, said Ginis.

If there is too much market reaction that means somebody learned some information about the direction of the trade. In that case, the ATS would adjust the matching periods to make them further apart, explains Ginis.  Instead of matching every 7 milliseconds, it can match every 3-10 milliseconds or 5-12 milliseconds. Then it can start shrinking the period between matches. “What the matching engine does is constantly find the optimal frequency in which to match such that it matches as often as possible, yet while the market response goes as close to zero as possible,” said Ginis. What you see coming out of the venue is a series of midpoint prints at randomized times, he said.

Slowing Down Executions

Chuck Mack, Deputy Head of US Equities, on the SIFMA panel

Chuck Mack, Deputy Head of US Equities, on the SIFMA panel

Other venues are also looking at reducing the frequency of trading to help institutions aggregate liquidity.

Nasdaq Stock Market has created the Midpoint Extended Life Order (M-ELO) “for participants for whom a millisecond or microsecond doesn’t matter,” said Chuck Mack, Deputy Head of US Equities, on the SIFMA panel. The dark order-type “is for participants or investors who are willing to be patient for just half-a-second and in return for that, anyone who wants to trade against them has to wait half a second,” he said. M-ELO orders will only execute against other M-ELO orders, which means they won’t be interacting with intermarket sweep orders (ISOs) or be subject to pinging, he said.  “It was created in a simple way to protect participants as much as we can from adverse selection and market impact,” said Mack.

Simplicity of Block Trading

In the public markets, where many traders are representing 100 share orders to buy or sell, institutions are vulnerable to adverse selection and information leakage. “It can be frustrating to assemble a block,” said Jonathan Clark, CEO of Luminex Trading & Analytics, an ATS that is owned and operated by a consortium of buy-side institutions.

“Governance and ownership structure is what makes us unique,” said Clark. Launched in 2015, Luminex was founded by nine asset managers, including Fidelity Investments, to serve as a utility-like venue for buy-side institutions. The other investors include Bank of New York Mellon Corp., BlackRock, Capital Group Cos., Invesco, JP Morgan Asset Management, MFS Investment Management and State Street Global Advisors and T. Rowe Price.

“We aren’t catering to broker-dealers. They don’t have access to the platform,” said Clark, adding that asset managers must come in through their OMS or EMS, so it’s a closed environment.

Jonathan Clark, CEO of Luminex Trading & Analytics

Jonathan Clark, CEO of Luminex Trading & Analytics

The formation of the buy-side dark pool was a reaction to some of the scandals that occurred with dark pools, such as the blow-up of Pipeline Trading after it leaked information about institutional clients to its market-making arm. “That sort of stuff gives pause to the buy side,” said Clark, a former buy-side trader on a quantitative team at Merrill Lynch Investment Management, which was acquired by BlackRock in 2006. Clark became co-head of equity trading at BlackRock until he joined Luminex.

Though skeptics had claimed the venue would not get matches since buy-side firms are on the same side of the trade, Clark said the ATS has data to prove otherwise. With a minimize size of 5,000 shares, Clark said Luminex’s average execution size is 30,000 shares, and the average quantity submitted is 160,000 shares.

FINRABased on FINRA data across all ATSs in the 10,000-share category, Luminex’s average trade size is 50,000 to 60,000 shares. Currently, Luminex has 180 subscribers in the market and feels that 200 will put it in good shape.

Despite the proliferation of order types in the market, Luminex is focused on the simplicity of block trading and only has two order types, said Clark. Cost is also a factor in Luminex’s growth. While some other block venues charge one to two cents per share, Luminex charges 25 mils (or .25 per 100 shares). He attributes some recent success to conditional orders where clients have an opportunity to rest an order in multiple places simultaneously.   “Clients have an opportunity to rest with us and to rest with other venues,” he said. Through an OMS or EMS, they can check a box and expose a one-million share order to BIDS and Luminex, he said.  “I can be in multiple places at the same time, and I can be patient,” said Clark.

Long Term Value Creation

By contrast to public exchanges that focus on high-speed trading, Long-Term Stock Exchange (LTSE) is in registration with the SEC to launch a stock exchange that allows listed companies to focus on long-term growth plans.

The exchange is looking to fight short-term thinking by creating new voting standards and disclosure rules which reward long-term shareholding. The idea was borne out of a book, The Lean Startup, in which author Eric Ries focused on how to help companies with innovation. Ries found out that startups and established companies are waiting longer to access the public markets. Ries proposes that startups will sell more shares to the public on LTSE because the rules will insulate them from short-term distractions and pressure from activist investors.

Michelle Greene, chief policy officer at LTSE

Michelle Greene, chief policy officer at LTSE

“As soon as companies enter the public marketplace they are facing quarterly scrutiny,” commented Michelle Greene, chief policy officer at LTSE. However, in the private marketplace, there was interest in how a company was executing on the long-term plan and growth, said Greene. Among the ideas is to provide disclosures that would give long-term investors more insight into what a company is planning for the long-term, and how they are measuring progress toward longer-term goals, said Greene, who is a former head of corporate responsibility at the New York Stock Exchange. Though it would be easier to register as an ATS, LTSE decided to register as an exchange. Greene said it would take the authority of an SRO [self regulatory organization] to make an ecosystem change.  In addition, LTSE struck an arrangement in December of 2017 with IEX, whereby companies that list on LTSE can trade on the IEX platform. The partnership, known as “LTSE Listings on IEX,”will provide a specialized set of listing standards for companies looking to go public while making a commitment to long-term value creation, reported Bloomberg. Until LTSE is approved to be an exchange, companies can get an LTSE listing standard on IEX, whose exchange is aligned with the idea of protecting investors from short-term predatory strategies.

Does Venue Proliferation Matter?

While US equity market structure is already complex, each ATS and exchange operator feels there is room in the market for innovation. Luminex’s Clark points out that when he was a buy-side trader, there were 50 dark pools operating, but some have closed their ATSs.  “So now there are sub-40, and so there’s been some consolidation in that arena,” said Clark.

According to Imperative’s Ginis, “The number of venues doesn’t really matter as much since they are all connected to each other. “Everyone builds just one book,” he said.  If he makes a decision to buy or sell stock and an order is routed via smart order router to Nasdaq or Arca, “it goes down one pipe to wherever I want to go.”

At the same time, major exchanges are floating the idea of launching more matching engines to differentiate their offerings.  As reported, Cboe Global Markets suggested it would light up medallions to increase its revenues if the regulators impose price controls on access fees and rebates. Also, Intercontinental Exchange (ICE), the owner of the NYSE, is expected to bring its fourth exchange, NYSE National, live in May, and ICE also agreed to acquire the Chicago Stock Exchange for a reported $70 million, reported S&P Global Market Intelligence.

Alluding to this trend, Clark said, “I know that exchanges have been buying up different medallions. That’s innovation,” he said.  “If you want to take a small venue and give it a go, Why not?  “I think innovation is what’s driving the market structure today. I don’t think it’s broken.”

Subscribe

Register now to receive the latest news and information for the global trading industry.






Latest Market News

Karthik Subramanian

Major Markets Trade Positive On Increased Risk Appetite

By Karthik Subramanian

Nikolas Papas

Kuroda Sparked a Yen Sell-Off

By Nikolas Papas

Michael Moran

Slip-Sliding Away, Dollar Drops for Third Day Running, Yields Fall

By Michael Moran

Karthik Subramanian

Profit Booking Post Holiday Thin Trading Session Paints Market in Red

By Karthik Subramanian

Nikolas Papas

Asian Stocks Mixed, EURUSD Flat around 1.13

By Nikolas Papas

LATEST INDUSTRY JOBS

Senior Identity Systems Engineer

Company: TEK systems

Location: Sydney, New South Wales, Australia

Analyst – Transaction Banking & Wholesale Lending

Company: ANZ

Location: Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Application Support Engineer – 12 month FTC

Company: ANZ

Location: Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Automation Consultant

Company: ANZ

Location: Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Relationship Manager – Retail Banking

Company: Kelly Executive

Location: Sydney, New South Wales, Australia

Latest Industry News

trueDigital and Credit Suisse Makes Important Senior Level Management Appointments

Coinbase Acquires Italian Blockchain Analytics Surveillance Company Neutrino

BNP Paribas Asset Management Adds Christopher Dunn as Global Head of Client Satisfaction

European Regulator ESMA Extends Ban on Binary Option for another Three Months Period

GBST Delivers Back-Office Custody Solution to Hong Kong Bank

Regulatory Announcements

Byte Power Pays $33,000 for Alleged Breach of Disclosure Obligations

SEC Charges Former Senior Attorney at Apple With Insider Trading

Deloitte Japan Charged With Violating Auditor Independence Rules

Court Restrains Advanced Wealth and Richard Gardner from Carrying on an Unlicensed Financial Services Business

Intercontinental Exchange and the NYSE Launch ‘Insights’

Cental Bank Announcements

Minutes of the Monetary Policy Meeting of the Reserve Bank Board

Trade Balance Subject to Global Headwinds in January 2019

Joachim Wuermeling: Brexit – implications for UK branches of German banks

Central Bank of Egypt’s overnight rate cut by 100 basis points

The Brexit Discontinuity – Governor Philp R. Lane

Trending New Stories

Crypto MidWeek Buzz: Markets, Morgan both reverse course on crypto

$462 Billion by 2030″: The Industry Reacts to Blockchain Forecast

OCBC Bank Expects to Save +$18 Million With Digital Security Token in 5 Years

Pound, Euro Post Modest Gains in Quiet, Holiday Trade

OANDA CEO Vatsa Narasimha Steps Down Citing Personal Reasons, Company Initiates Search for a New CEO

Trending News Stories

Major Markets Trade Positive On Increased Risk Appetite

trueDigital and Credit Suisse Makes Important Senior Level Management Appointments

Coinbase Acquires Italian Blockchain Analytics Surveillance Company Neutrino

Kuroda Sparked a Yen Sell-Off

Minutes of the Monetary Policy Meeting of the Reserve Bank Board

Crypto MidWeek Buzz: Markets, Morgan both reverse course on crypto

Slip-Sliding Away, Dollar Drops for Third Day Running, Yields Fall

Profit Booking Post Holiday Thin Trading Session Paints Market in Red

Asian Stocks Mixed, EURUSD Flat around 1.13

BNP Paribas Asset Management Adds Christopher Dunn as Global Head of Client Satisfaction

More than just a news source

Links

  • Become an Advertising Partner
  • Contact Us
  • Industry Directory

Social Media

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin

Subscribe

Register now to receive the latest news and information for global trading industry.

Copyright © 2016 — The Industry Spread Pty Ltd • All rights reserved. • Privacy Policy • Disclaimer

The information contained on this website is of a general nature only. The information does not constitute advice or a recommendation on any course of action and does not take into account your personal circumstances, financial situation or individual needs. We strongly recommend you to seek independent professional advice or to conduct your own independent research before acting upon any information contained on this website.

Information presented on this website includes but is not limited to those of brokers and technology and service providers. You should be cautious about any information on this website and should consider its source. Various factors, including personal or corporate ownership, may influence the information. The information contained on this website is only as accurate as at the date it was published. References to past performance is no guarantee of future performance.

Please read our Terms and Conditions.

All rights reserved.

This website, and the information which it contains, is the intellectual property of The Industry Spread Pty Ltd (ACN 612 938 360) and its affiliates and licensors, and is protected from unauthorised copying and dissemination by Australian law, international conventions and other intellectual property laws. All The Industry Spread product and service names and logos are owned The Industry Spread Pty Ltd. All other company and product names and logos are trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective owners in certain countries.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok